Joseph says that the product of a four digit number and a 1 digit number is always a four digit number does joe didn't make sense

The answer is no. Not always.
There are times that the 4 digit number will involve carrying and it will be resulted into 5 digit number.
For example:
9 999 x 9, where 9 999 is a 4 digit number and 9 is a 1 digit number.
When you multiply this one, the answer will be 5 digit number.
9 999
x     9
=> 89 991, thus Joseph's statement does not apply to all multiplication process because  not all 4 digit number multiplied with 1 digit number will result to 4 digit.

Answer is a not really sure tho