(a) Explain what is wrong with the following ‘proof’:Statement:IfRis symmetric and transitive, thenRis reflexive."Proof":SupposeRis symmetric and transitive. Symmetric means thatx R yimpliesy R x. We apply transitivity tox R yandy R xto givex R x. Therefore, Ris reflexive.(b) Give an example of a relation on a set that is both symmetric and tran-sitive, but not reflexive

Step-by-step explanation:

Recall that, in this case, the subset of X for which R is defined is called the domain of R. The mistake occurs when we assume that the domain R is the whole set X, but it could happen that R is not defined for some elements of X.

Recall the following example:

X = {2,4,6}.

We can define R as follows {(2,2), (4,4), (2,4), (4,2)}. We can easily check that this is a transitive and symmetric relation, but since we don't have the element (6,6) it fails to be reflexive.

i get you, what you should do is think of the positive things that would come out of it. it will make yours parents proud and raise your grade. you should always try and if you can't focus tell the teacher.