Guyys helpp Directions: Determine which statements are claims and which statements are counterclaims for the given argument. Then, choose the best counterclaim statement and complete the sentence frame. In the boxes beside the statements, write “c” for claims, and write “cc” for counterclaims.

Argument: Participation trophies do more harm than good.

boost self-confidence should not replace coach feedback
don’t recognize and reward the right goals acknowledge hard word
keep kids engaged and wanting to play eliminate lessons learned from losing
take away motivation to improve look good on bedroom shelves

Counterclaim & Rebuttal:
On the other hand, (state the counterclaim)

but, I argue (argue your claim)


Argument: Students should be required to take summer school.
Summer School…
costs money that could be spent elsewhere restricts kids from being able to recharge
improves and advances academic skills may not offer regular bus transportation
provides a break from a more structured year allows for more personalized relationships
keeps kids occupied and out of trouble is more difficult than expected

Counterclaim & Rebuttal:
On the other hand, (state the counterclaim)

but, I argue (argue your claim)