Thomas Edison said, "There is no substitute for hard work." However, some people believe that talent is the most important factor in success. Which do you believe will help a person reach his or her goals in life? Write an essay convincing your friends which is more important: talent or hard work

Jonas wrote this claim in response to the prompt:

Hard work is the most important element in success because even the most talented people need to work hard to reach their full potential.

Which statement best explains how effectively Jonas's claim responds to the prompt?

A. The claim is ineffective because although it gives a clear point of view, it does not respond directly to the prompt.

B. The claim is effective because it includes factual information needed to support the argument.

C. The claim is ineffective because although it addresses the prompt, it doesn't take a stand on the issue.

D. The claim is effective because it clearly addresses the prompt, takes a stand, and backs up its viewpoint with reasons.