In economics, what is the meaning of the phrase 'the tragedy of the commons? ' in market economies products are often similar and common, so the government must actively attempt to create variety in goods and services. in decisions involving intellectual property rights, policy-makers must compromise in order to reach common ground among competing interest groups. people will overuse or misuse a common resource that is not excludable but is rivalrous. it serves the common good to produce items that are neither rivalrous nor excludable, but profit‑maximizing firms will not produce such products. goods that are not rivalrous but are excludable are under‐produced by private markets, often with consequences that reduce social welfare.

Onsider the following subscription behavior information from genie, a web site that provides tools for constructing a family tree (ancestor search). subscriptions cost $9.99 per month, but you are charged for the entire year at the time of purchase. there is a one-year minimum term when you sign up for the service. once purchased, subscriptions are set to renew automatically unless the subscriber cancels them. when a membership renews, it renews for a one-year term and again you are charged for the entire year. there are no variable costs associated with providing this service to an individual customer, but genie does engage in customer relationship activities that they believe will increase customer retention. these customer relationship activities cost genie about $10 per year per customer. based on a sample of 1000 customers that joined genie five years ago, near the time when the company was founded, they were able to determine how many of those customers remained subscribers in the second year, third year etc. based on this information, genie calculated the average annual retention rate to be 20%. genie uses an annual discount rate of 8%. a. last year, genie spent $10,000 placing advertisements on google. genie management believes that these advertisements were responsible for about 300 new subscribers. would you recommend to genie management that they purchase more google ads? b. suppose a newly-introduced loyalty program increases the number of customers that remained to 30%. does this new data change your answer to 9.a? c. do you have any hesitations or concerns about making recommendations to management based on your above estimate of customer lifetime value?